Review bdip 03 for inaccuracies

Updates Y/N?
Updates Yes
Date
Apr 16, 2023
bDIP Stages
Archive
Done
Steward/Author
Ernest of Gaia 536305592806146059
Type
research
Priority
High
Intake Stage
Final Reviewer
Person
Action Stage
OKR or KPI
resolve inaccuracies suggest it is a temp check and not a bdip
Success Metrics
clear status of bdip
Word Count
Total Labour Hours to date
Submitter of Final Draft for Review
Publisher of BDIP
jengo jojo
 
  • two different options in question here?
    • the two different options are not in the polls
    • notion image
  • Which specific parts do not follow the template?
    • While you use the bdip template for option B (old text new text) you do not apply the template to Option A. Again you are suggesting (temp checking) 2 different options in this proposal. If this is just a proposal for Option B, Option A should be removed. If this is asking us which option we prefer than this is a temp check and should include a Poll for folks that want Option A or even a third Option, a rejection of both of your options
  • a bdip needs one clear set of textual changes to the constitution that propose one initiative by definition of being a proposal. It is against logic and reason to suggest 2 options and then only lay out one poll for one option.

Review bdip 03 for inaccuracies

Updates Y/N?
Updates Yes
Date
Apr 16, 2023
bDIP Stages
Archive
Done
Steward/Author
Ernest of Gaia 536305592806146059
Type
research
Priority
High
Intake Stage
Final Reviewer
Person
Action Stage
OKR or KPI
resolve inaccuracies suggest it is a temp check and not a bdip
Success Metrics
clear status of bdip
Word Count
Total Labour Hours to date
Submitter of Final Draft for Review
Publisher of BDIP
jengo jojo
 
  • two different options in question here?
    • the two different options are not in the polls
    • notion image
  • Which specific parts do not follow the template?
    • While you use the bdip template for option B (old text new text) you do not apply the template to Option A. Again you are suggesting (temp checking) 2 different options in this proposal. If this is just a proposal for Option B, Option A should be removed. If this is asking us which option we prefer than this is a temp check and should include a Poll for folks that want Option A or even a third Option, a rejection of both of your options
  • a bdip needs one clear set of textual changes to the constitution that propose one initiative by definition of being a proposal. It is against logic and reason to suggest 2 options and then only lay out one poll for one option.